Mentor RIA Consulting - Allowing you to focus on what you do best

Recent Posts

Sales Incentives: Who Really Pays?
Could an IRA Trust Work for Your Plan?
Is the Pandemic Changing Your Plans?
Form CRS: Prop or Flop?
Using 401(k) Loans for Short Term Liquidity


RIA Business
powered by

My Blog

RMD Rules: Time for a Change?

Most folks with a qualified retirement plan account – 401(k), 457, 403(b), IRA – know about the required minimum distribution rules that force account holders to begin taking distributions (in most cases) no later than the year they attain age 70½. Currently, it appears that the government is looking at potential changes to these rules, at least with respect to 401(k) accounts.
The existing rule is intended to serve the purpose of these accounts, which is helping retirees fund their retirements. At the same time, it allows the IRS to finally capture some of those taxes which were previously deferred, although often at lower rates than applied when the deferrals were originally made. So we know immediately that any extension or limitation of the existing rule will reduce the anticipated tax revenue by pushing it to a future, unknown time.
Not surprisingly, advocates for the change suggest the current rules are unfair as they force account holders to withdraw funds instead of being able to let them grow longer. That argument suffers from two major flaws: contributions were made with the expectation of withdrawals under the existing rule and there is nothing that says wealthier account holders need to spend their withdrawals – they can certainly reinvest them to the extent they are not consumed.
Further light on this proposal comes from recent research showing that a significant proportion of account holders with smaller balances (under a quarter of a million dollars) actually take out more than the required minimum distribution. They need that money and cannot afford to leave it to grow. At bottom, this simply suggests that wealthier account holders could benefit to some extent by the additional deferral while the less fortunate will have no benefit. Is changing the rule to benefit the few really where we need to be spending our energy and time? 

1 Comment to RMD Rules: Time for a Change?:

Comments RSS
parfait chaussures gucci on Monday, December 24, 2018 3:44 PM
I really like this informative blog and looking forward for more posts.
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment
Website Builder provided by  Vistaprint